The "To Keep Up" Wiki

Fusion Update

The meeting covered a comprehensive fusion power update, including historical context, scientific principles, and current reactor developments. Commonwealth Fusion Systems presented their progress on the Arc fusion reactor project, including updates on the Spark Tokamak prototype and plans for a full-scale power plant in Virginia. The conversation ended with discussions on fusion technology economics, materials development, and next week's agenda.

Ted Kochanski outlined the agenda for the fusion power update, covering topics such as the history and science of fusion, the Lawson criterion, and the development of a Tokamak-based fusion reactor. He discussed the potential for fusion to address future energy demands, particularly in relation to AI and data center energy consumption. The presentation included comparisons of fusion and fission fuels, highlighting fusion's advantages such as inexhaustible fuel supply, cleanliness, and safety.

Ted discussed the history of nuclear fusion, highlighting Arthur Eddington's speculation about harnessing stellar energy on Earth and Cecilia Payne's work at Harvard showing hydrogen's abundance in stars. He explained George Gamow's introduction of quantum tunneling and Mark Oliphant's 1933 experiment at the Cavendish Laboratory, which demonstrated the first nuclear fusion reaction using deuterium, observing both helium production and tritons. Despite the AI summary's claim, Oliphant did not use tritium in his experiments, and his work laid the foundation for future fusion research and nuclear energy development.

Ted discussed nuclear fusion reactions, focusing on the binding energy curve and the challenges of overcoming the Coulomb potential barrier. He explained that fusion reactions require high temperatures and the assistance of quantum mechanics and distribution functions to occur. Ted highlighted the four viable fusion reactions, noting that D-D and D-T have the best cross-sections and require lower temperatures, while reactions involving boron-11 and helium-3 are more challenging due to their higher temperature requirements and lack of neutron production.

Ted explained the concepts of break-even and ignition in fusion reactions, referencing Lawson's original paper and Sam Wurzel's updated work. He discussed the Lawson criteria, Q-fuel, and the challenges of achieving a useful thermonuclear reactor. Ted highlighted that today's focus is on both Q-scientific (break-even) and Q-engineering (10 or higher) goals, with projects like ITER and SPARK aiming to reach these targets. He also clarified that Q greater than one is necessary for a useful power plant, contrasting it with the incorrect analogy provided by the AI.

Ted discussed the history and progress of Tokamak fusion reactors, highlighting key milestones and achievements. He explained the concept of scientific break-even, where the energy produced equals the energy input, and noted that only two fusion concepts have achieved this. Ted also described the Joint European Torus (JET) and its production of 69 megajoules of energy in 2024, which he compared to the energy usage of an average US home. He concluded by reviewing the progress of various Tokamak projects around the world, including those in Korea, France, and China.

Ted explained the basic components and operation of a Tokamak, including the central solenoid, toroidal and poloidal magnetic fields, and plasma confinement. He discussed the challenges of plasma instabilities, material erosion, and the need for breeding blankets to produce tritium. Ted also outlined the structure of a fusion power plant, highlighting the plasma core, breeding blanket, magnets, and auxiliary systems needed for heat extraction and electricity generation.

Commonwealth Fusion is developing a fusion power reactor called Arc, which is based on high-temperature superconductors and uses a Tokamak design. The company is building the Spark Tokamak prototype near Boston to test key technologies, with plans to complete construction this year and begin operations next year. Their head engineer explained that the reactor will use molten salt (FLiBe) to capture neutrons and generate electricity, similar to traditional power plants. The company is also working on the pre-conceptual design of the full-scale Arc power plant, which will be built in Virginia, and is addressing challenges in materials, tritium production, and scaling up production of superconducting materials needed for fusion reactors.

The meeting focused on a virtual tour of the Spark fusion power plant site in Richmond, Virginia, led by Alex Creeley, who highlighted recent progress and ongoing assembly of the Tokamak. Ted addressed questions about equipment durability, explaining that the machine is designed for 13,000 discharges over 10 years, with potential for damage from disruptive instabilities. The discussion concluded with an announcement about the site selection for the first ARC fusion power plant in Chesterfield County, Virginia, and plans to incorporate lessons learned into the design.

We watched a news roundup on significant developments in nuclear fusion, highlighting a major funding milestone of £2.5 billion over five years from the UK government for fusion energy, the largest single contribution to fusion by the UK. This also discussed Proxima Fusion's record funding round of €130 million, led by Cherry Ventures and Balderton Capital, and new research by UCSD on void propagation in fusion plasmas, which could improve turbulence prediction in fusion power plants. Bonus stories included fusion research in gaming algorithms by UNIST and the announcement of the Hacks Plasma Forge Innovation Center in New Jersey with $49 million in funding.

The group discussed the economics and development timeline of fusion power technology, with Ted explaining that fusion reactors would likely cost about a third as much as fission plants due to reduced reactor costs, though overall costs might not be significantly lower. He outlined that the spark machine under construction would produce hydrogen plasmas by late 2026, with deuterium plasmas and fusion reactions expected by 2028, while the arc machine in Virginia would be in final design phase by 2028.

The group discussed the materials and manufacturing processes for superconducting magnets, with Ted explaining that the magnets use a rare earth barium copper oxide material and are currently produced by a Japanese company called Faraday. Carl noted that while rare earth elements are abundant, their processing is controlled by China, though Ted suggested this would be temporary as new refining methods are developed.